Stories

Why giving makes you happier

People who give are, on average, more satisfied with their lives. But does giving really make you happier? What the research does and doesn't show.

A smiling woman helps an older man with a bag of shopping
Photo: Kampus Production on Pexels
In this story
  1. The envelope experiment
  2. Not just in rich countries
  3. What happens in your head
  4. When it works best
  5. What this means for Karma Points

Imagine: this morning you get an envelope with twenty euros. You have to spend it today. What will make you happier tonight: buying something for yourself, or something for someone else?

Most people think: something for myself. Research says otherwise, although the story is less simple than it is often told.

The envelope experiment

In 2008 the psychologists Elizabeth Dunn, Lara Aknin and Michael Norton did exactly this. In the morning they gave people an envelope with five or twenty dollars. Half had to spend it on themselves, the other half on someone else or a charity. By the evening, the people who had given to others were happier. They published it in the journal Science.

It became a famous study, but it was small: 46 participants. A larger replication with 133 people found no clear difference using the same analysis, and the researchers' own replication gave a mixed picture. So the envelope experiment is not hard proof that giving makes you happier.

Not just in rich countries

What does stand firm is the link. In 2013 Aknin and colleagues looked at data from 136 countries. In 120 of them, people who had given to a charity in the past month were more satisfied with their lives. In poor countries too, and also when you take income into account. But a link is not proof: perhaps satisfied people simply give more often.

Even very young children show it. In another study by Aknin, toddlers were happier when they gave a treat away than when they received one themselves.

What happens in your head

In 2007 researchers had people decide about money for a food bank while lying in a brain scanner. Giving lit up the same areas as receiving a reward. And the effect was stronger when people chose to give than when the money was taken from them as a compulsory payment.

Economists have long had a name for it: warm glow, the warm feeling of giving. The economist James Andreoni described it in 1990. We don't only give because the cause needs our money, but also because giving itself feels good.

When it works best

Giving doesn't always make you happy. A review of 201 studies found a modest link, stronger for a sense of meaning than for pleasure in the moment. And research points to things that help:

  • You choose it yourself. Giving because you have to, or because someone pushes you, does less.
  • You see what it does. People felt better when they knew exactly what their gift achieved than when it stayed a vague "it helps". This is the best-supported point.
  • You feel a connection. Giving to someone or something you know works more strongly than giving to something abstract.

It's not about how much you give, but whether you know what it does and for whom.

What this means for Karma Points

This research is one of the reasons Karma Points works the way it does. You choose a cause yourself, often in your own neighbourhood. And every cause shows what your contribution achieves: so many meals, so many hours of help. With the impact calculator you can work it out before you give.

So the next time you have twenty euros to spare: give it a try. Choose a cause, and see how you feel tonight. Read more about giving well in the giving guide.


Sources: Dunn, Aknin & Norton, "Spending money on others promotes happiness", Science (2008). Aknin et al., "Prosocial spending and well-being", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2013). Aknin, Hamlin & Dunn, "Giving leads to happiness in young children", PLoS ONE (2012). Kim et al., replication in PLoS ONE (2022). Hui et al., meta-analysis of 201 studies (2020). Harbaugh, Mayr & Burghart, "Neural responses to taxation and voluntary giving", Science (2007). Andreoni, "Impure altruism and donations to public goods", The Economic Journal (1990).

  • #behaviour
  • #happiness
  • #research
Share

From reading to doing.

Pick a charity near you and see exactly what your contribution does.